Negative Use Cases in AI: Handling Them in Prompt Engineering
.svg)
Table of Contents
Introduction
When building AI-powered chatbots, much attention is given to designing prompts that produce accurate and helpful responses. However, handling negative use cases in AI is equally critical to successful prompt engineering – situations where the chatbot needs to reject a request or deliver a “no” response. These scenarios can range from the chatbot lacking the required information to the user’s request falling outside the system’s capabilities.
Effectively managing negative use cases is key to maintaining user satisfaction, even when the AI cannot provide the desired outcome. In this blog, we’ll explore the importance of handling negative use cases and offer strategies for crafting prompts that gracefully manage such interactions without frustrating the user.
Importance of Handling Negative Use Cases
Negative use cases arise when:
- The chatbot does not have the necessary information.
- The user asks a question that exceeds the chatbot’s capabilities.
- The request is beyond the scope of available configurations or data.
- The system needs to refuse an action that is unsupported or potentially harmful.
Addressing these use cases effectively is important because:
- It helps manage user expectations by clearly communicating system limitations.
- It ensures that the chatbot doesn’t provide incorrect or misleading information.
- It keeps the conversation productive, guiding the user toward alternative solutions, resources, or escalation paths.
- Handling these scenarios properly prevents user frustration and enhances the overall experience.
Best Practices for Engineering Prompts in Negative Use Cases
Here are some of the recommended best practices:
Identify Common Scenarios for Denial
Begin by identifying situations where the chatbot might need to refuse a request. These could include unsupported configurations, unavailable data, or actions that require admin-level access.
Example:
User Query: “Can I delete a user account as a business user?”
Response: “Only Admins have the ability to delete user accounts. Would you like to request this action from an Admin?”
Use Polite, Soft Language
When denying a request, avoid abrupt responses. Instead, use polite language that softens the denial and guides users toward alternative options.
Example:
User Query: “Can I bypass two-factor authentication?”
Response: “For security reasons, two-factor authentication cannot be bypassed. However, I can assist you with account recovery if you’re having trouble.”
Provide Justifications
A good negative response explains why the request can’t be fulfilled. This helps the user understand the system’s limitations.
Example:
User Query: “Can I install third-party apps on Salesforce?”
Response: “Installing third-party apps requires Admin permissions due to security protocols. Please contact your Admin for further assistance.”
Offer Alternatives or Next Steps
Whenever possible, provide an alternative solution or action the user can take, keeping the conversation moving forward.
Example:
User Query: “Can I disable the backup feature?”
Response: “Disabling backups is not recommended due to the risk of data loss. I suggest adjusting the backup settings instead or contacting your Admin.”
Facilitate Escalation to Human Agents
When the chatbot cannot resolve a query, ensure there is a smooth transition to a human agent. Clearly communicate this to the user to prevent them from feeling stuck.
Example:
User Query: “I need help with a complex Salesforce configuration.”
Response: “It seems like this issue is beyond my expertise. I’ll connect you with a support agent who can assist further.”
Ask Clarifying Questions
Before outright denying a request, ask clarifying questions to fully understand the user’s intent. This can help prevent unnecessary rejections and potentially guide the user toward something the chatbot can assist with.
Example:
User Query: “Can I run custom scripts as a business user?”
Response: “Could you specify the type of scripts? Some customizations require Admin permissions, but I can help with those available to business users.”
Learn more about designing effective prompts in our blog on Prompt Engineering for AI Systems.
Incorporating Negative Use Cases into AI Systems
Incorporating well-crafted negative use case handling into AI systems is essential for maintaining user satisfaction. Here are key strategies:
- Refinement of Negative Response Prompts: Develop a comprehensive set of prompts that explain why certain requests can’t be fulfilled, while guiding users toward next steps.
- Seamless Escalation: Ensure the chatbot smoothly transitions users to human support when necessary.
- Role-Based Responses: Tailor prompts based on the user’s role (e.g., Admin, Business User), ensuring that each response is relevant to the user’s permissions and capabilities.
Examples of Negative Use Case Handling
Effectively handling negative use cases requires clear communication and offering users alternative actions or explanations. Below are examples that illustrate how to manage common scenarios where the chatbot cannot fulfill a user’s request:
Example 1:
User Query: “Can I retrieve detailed usage logs as a business user?”
Response: “Access to detailed logs is restricted to Admins for security purposes. Would you like to learn more about the permissions required for this action?”
Explanation: In this case, the chatbot informs the user about the access limitations in a clear and polite way. Instead of a flat denial, the response offers the user an option to learn more about the necessary permissions, maintaining a positive and informative interaction.
Example 2:
User Query: “Can I disable the backup feature in Salesforce?”
Response: “Disabling backups is not recommended as it can lead to data loss. I suggest exploring the backup settings to customize your preferences or contact your Admin for further guidance.”
Explanation: The response provides a reasoned explanation for why the action should not be performed, warning the user of potential consequences. At the same time, it offers the user alternatives—customizing preferences or contacting an Admin—keeping the conversation productive and offering clear next steps.
These examples highlight how to handle negative use cases without frustrating the user. By offering explanations, alternatives, and actionable suggestions, the chatbot can maintain user trust and engagement even when it has to say “no.”
Conclusion
Handling negative use cases in AI is a crucial part of building effective AI-powered chatbots through prompt engineering. By designing prompts that gracefully handle these situations, you can ensure your chatbot provides clear, user-friendly responses that maintain satisfaction even when a request can’t be fulfilled. Thoughtful prompt engineering keeps the conversation productive, offers alternatives, and prevents user frustration.
Ready to Transform with AI?
More Insights for you
Ready to Transform Your Business with Salesforce & AI?
